Skip to content
Next Blackjack Point

The Console Cycle That Torched Games-as-a-Service

Over the course of a quarter-century, game developers have chased after ongoing gaming experiences. Trailblazing titles like World of Warcraft changed single-purchase customers into loyal paying users, sparking a period of imitators attempting to copy those results. In spite of many attempts, few managed to dethrone the top dogs.

The drive for the subsequent long-lasting title escalated with the rise of billion-dollar powerhouses like Minecraft, several of which have led user activity over many years. Their persistent dominance inspired publishers to place huge gambles during the latest hardware era.

Full of funds and confidence, leading companies like Sony sought to transform themselves as live-service providers, often overlooking their own strengths. Those companies are known for superb offline titles, but that success failed to secure a smooth transition into the demanding world of social , forever-updated , in-game purchase-driven gaming experiences.

Beginning in the launch year of the PlayStation 5 and the new Xbox, dozens of high-stakes GaaS games have appeared and vanished. Several have collapsed publicly, resulting in widespread job cuts, project terminations, and company collapses. Subsequent to huge increases, followed unwise investments, and aftermath that may represent a “adjustment” of the market, but also equates to the disappearance of many thousands of jobs.

How Did We Get Here?

In the mid-2010s, leading companies like Square Enix recognized games-as-a-service as a key priority for their businesses. Their market value grew dramatically during the last ten years, thanks in part to the monetization strategy behind its recurring sports titles. A rival firm had comparable growth, due to persistent games like Overwatch.

Also in that same year, a major studio launched the popular title, which swiftly started bringing in vast amounts of currency monthly. The game's genre change secured the developer an approximate nine billion dollars in its first two years.

While the latest hardware approached and launched, the U.S. video game market rose from a huge sum in 2019 to $58.2 billion in the next period, partly because of higher consumer outlay caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. In the subsequent year, the U.S. market attained an all-time high. Studios, striving to carve out their niche in the GaaS arena, and boosted by low interest rates, rapidly grew, hiring numerous of new employees and starting projects — several GaaS titles. The results of these choices would have a lasting impact for the foreseeable future.

The Failures Happened Fast

One major publisher attempted to replicate an existing hit's success with games like Babylon’s Fall, which failed. A different publisher tried to branch out beyond its story-driven , solo , and accessible titles with a similar ongoing experience, and a derived fighter. Work has ended on both. Sega scrapped the live-service shooter Hyenas after a long time of development, ahead of the game actually launched. Independent developers attempted to succeed in the live-service market; a few releases are also casualties of the live-service gamble. One developer's recent financial woes can be chalked up to the inability of an FPS to turn fans of a previous hit into live-service shooter fans.

Perhaps the most significant gamble on GaaS originated with a console manufacturer, which acquired the popular franchise creator Bungie for $3.6 billion and then declared plans to launch numerous GaaS titles by 2026. That included a eventually abandoned online title featuring a popular IP, a reportedly scrapped game based on another series, and the infamous Concord, which ceased operations and saw its complete company disbanded just weeks after debut.

The publisher has since retreated from those lofty goals, focusing on its players with the AAA single-player fare it's famous for, like Astro Bot. The status of teased live-service games like one upcoming title remains uncertain. The company's upcoming major bet, the new title, will be a crucial trial for the troubled maker.

Why Did So Many Fail?

A major cause is that many consumers have already invested immensely, through commitment and expenditure, into existing titles like Call of Duty. The battle for the long-term hit, for a lot of gamers, was already decided in the prior console cycle. A lot of those long-running hits still dominate engagement rankings across PC, Switch, PS5, and Microsoft systems.

Modern Hits

Several newer live-service titles have broken through. A leading studio is finding early success with the Battlefield 6, titles that have been thoroughly playtested and shaped by the dedicated fans behind them. A separate studio gained popularity with a superhero title, combining a familiarity with Marvel’s brand and the established formula of a popular shooter. A console maker and a developer made an impact with their cooperative shooter, using a blend of polished systems and effective user outreach.

Many game makers seem to have learned the lesson: The available resources and attention to {

Written by

Richard Smith

A professional blackjack strategist with over 15 years of experience in casinos worldwide, specializing in card counting and risk management.

Next Blackjack Point

Type to search articles.